If you suspect a hip fracture, do not wait for a clinic appointment. An older person with groin pain or unable to bear weight after a fall needs urgent assessment: call 166 or 112, or go to a hospital emergency department. Clinic appointments are for second opinions, follow-up and rehabilitation.
In short. Not every femoral neck fracture needs a joint replacement. Undisplaced fractures are usually fixed with screws and the femoral head is kept. Displaced fractures in older adults are usually treated with a hemiarthroplasty or a total hip replacement. When a replacement is needed, Dr Skotidis uses the anterior ASI approach in suitable patients or the lateral Hardinge approach, depending on the clinical circumstances.
What a femoral neck fracture is
The femoral neck is the narrow part that joins the head of the thigh bone to the rest of the bone. Because it sits inside the joint, a break here can cut the vessels that feed the femoral head. That is why there is a risk that the fracture will not heal or that the head will develop osteonecrosis.
What matters most for treatment is whether the pieces have shifted. The Garden classification has four grades; in practice, grades I and II are undisplaced and grades III and IV are displaced fractures.
Who it affects
- Older adults with osteoporosis, after a simple fall from standing height. This is the most common case.
- Younger people after high-energy trauma such as a road accident, where the aim is to save their own femoral head.
- People with weak bone from other causes, such as long-term cortisone use or kidney disease.
Symptoms
- Pain in the groin or thigh after a fall.
- Not being able to stand or walk.
- In displaced fractures, the leg looks shorter and turned outwards.
Note: with an undisplaced fracture a patient may walk in pain for a few days. An older person with hip pain after a fall needs an X-ray, even if they can walk.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis is made with a pelvic X-ray and a lateral view of the hip. When the X-ray is negative but suspicion remains, international guidelines advise an MRI scan, or a CT scan if MRI is not available. The pre-operative check-up starts at the same time: blood tests, ECG and an anaesthetic assessment.
Why surgery is done quickly
NICE guidance advises surgery on the day of admission or the day after. Delay and bed rest raise the risk of pneumonia, blood clots, pressure sores and confusion. The time is used to adjust medication such as blood thinners, so that the operation is safe.
Undisplaced fracture: fixation
When the pieces have not shifted, the fracture is usually fixed internally with parallel cannulated screws or a sliding hip screw, and the femoral head is kept. In the large randomised FAITH trial, the two techniques did not differ significantly in reoperations overall.
In selected older patients with poor bone quality or existing joint wear, joint replacement may be discussed even for an undisplaced fracture.
Displaced fracture: hemiarthroplasty or total hip replacement
In older adults, a displaced femoral neck fracture is usually treated with joint replacement, because fixation has a high failure rate.
- Hemiarthroplasty: only the femoral head is replaced. Preferred for patients with limited mobility or serious health problems.
- Total hip replacement: both the head and the socket are replaced. NICE recommends it for patients who walked outdoors with no more than one stick before the fracture, have no significant cognitive impairment and are fit for the operation.
In the HEALTH trial (NEJM 2019), total hip replacement and hemiarthroplasty did not differ significantly in secondary procedures at two years. Total hip replacement gave a small functional benefit, with more dislocations. The choice is made individually, together with the patient and family.
In younger patients, a displaced fracture is treated urgently with reduction and fixation, to preserve their own joint.
The approach for replacement after a fracture: ASI or Hardinge
For joint replacement after a femoral neck fracture, Dr Skotidis uses two approaches:
- The anterior ASI approach, in suitable patients. The joint is reached from the front, between the muscles, without detaching them. See the anterior ASI approach.
- The lateral Hardinge approach, when the clinical circumstances make it more suitable. The joint is reached from the side of the hip, detaching part of the abductor muscles, which are then repaired.
The choice depends on the fracture pattern, bone quality, general health and anatomy, and on whether a hemiarthroplasty or a total hip replacement is planned. In a review of 21 studies with Dr Skotidis as first author (Cureus, 2023), the anterior approach was linked to a lower dislocation rate than the posterior approach in older patients having a total hip replacement after a femoral neck fracture. It is a narrative review, not a direct comparison with the Hardinge approach, and it does not mean ASI suits every patient.
Fast Track: early mobilisation and organised post-operative care
Fast Track means an organised care pathway around the operation, aiming to get the patient up early and safely. It does not mean rushing, and it does not promise discharge at a fixed time. In hip fracture, where patients are often older with other health problems, the pace is adjusted to each person.
- Pre-operative assessment and optimisation of medicines and conditions (blood thinners, diabetes, heart, hydration), so surgery can happen quickly but safely.
- Pain relief combining methods, such as a nerve block and medicines, to control pain with fewer opioids.
- Team care: orthopaedic surgeon, anaesthetist, physician or geriatrician and physiotherapist.
- Getting up on the day of surgery or the next day, when the patient’s condition allows, with daily physiotherapy.
- Preventing complications: blood clots, delirium, pneumonia, pressure sores, and good nutrition.
- Planned discharge: instructions, walking aids, physiotherapy at home or in a rehabilitation centre, and follow-up appointments.
NICE hip fracture guidance recommends this kind of organised, multidisciplinary care and mobilisation no later than the day after surgery unless there is a medical reason not to. Length of stay and recovery vary from patient to patient.
When treatment without surgery is considered
Very rarely. It is considered only when general health allows no operation at all, or for patients who were already bedbound and would not benefit. The aim then is pain control and care.
Recovery after surgery
- Getting up from the next day, with the physiotherapist. In most cases full weight bearing is allowed.
- Preventing delirium: familiar faces, glasses and hearing aids, quiet sleep at night.
- Nutrition with enough protein, and good hydration.
- Osteoporosis treatment to prevent the next fracture. See osteoporosis.
- Fall prevention with balance exercises and a safe home.
Complications and warning signs
After fixation, the main complications are non-union and osteonecrosis of the head, which may lead to joint replacement. After replacement, the main ones are dislocation, infection and periprosthetic fracture. Every hip fracture carries a risk of blood clots.
- New or worse hip pain, or a leg that suddenly turns and shortens.
- Fever, or a wound that turns red or leaks fluid.
- Calf swelling and pain, chest pain or shortness of breath: call 166 (or 112).
- New or worse confusion.
For patients in Porto Rafti and East Attica
A hip fracture needs a hospital. Dr Skotidis operates at Metropolitan General in Cholargos, Athens. Follow-up after discharge can take place at the Porto Rafti clinic, close to those living in Artemida, Koropi, Keratea, Markopoulo, Vravrona, Spata and Paiania. For appointments see the contact page.
Common questions
Is a femoral neck fracture the same as a hip fracture?
It is one of the two main types of hip fracture. The other is the intertrochanteric fracture, which happens a little lower, outside the joint, and is treated differently.
Why do some patients get a replacement and others screws?
Because in a femoral neck fracture the blood supply to the head can be lost. When the fracture has not shifted, the head is usually saved with screws. When it has shifted in an older person, replacement is more reliable.
How long is the hospital stay?
Usually a few days, followed by rehabilitation at home or in a centre, depending on mobility before the fracture and the support available.
References
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Hip fracture: management. Clinical guideline CG124. 2011, last updated 2023. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg124
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS). Management of Hip Fractures in Older Adults: Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline. 2021.
- FAITH Investigators. Fracture fixation in the operative management of hip fractures (FAITH): an international, multicentre, randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2017;389(10078):1519-1527. PMID: 28262269. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30066-1
- HEALTH Investigators. Total hip arthroplasty or hemiarthroplasty for hip fracture. N Engl J Med. 2019;381(23):2199-2208. PMID: 31557429. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1906190
- Skotidis E, Bekas K, Kechagias I, Tsakonas-Ntervakos I, Galanakos SP, Kateros K. Dislocation of Total Hip Arthroplasty of Femoral Neck Fracture in the Elderly: A Narrative Review. Cureus. 2023;15(10):e46307. PMID: 37916228. doi:10.7759/cureus.46307. Erratum: Cureus. 2025;17(8):c264, doi:10.7759/cureus.c264 (corrects a typographical error in the number of included studies, from 20 to 21; conclusions unchanged).
Last substantive update: . This information is educational and does not replace a medical examination.